Snickers and Turtles Pie. Can we call it Snickurtle ???
I don’t know what/who/how to name this pie… it’s a pie where a snickers bar and a turtle candy meet and make a baby.
Then their baby is frozen.
And then that baby will soon become your new favorite ice cream/pie/cheesecake.
But there isn’t an actual snickers bar nor a turtle candy in there. It’s all homemade.
Look at that delicious mess!
I got this recipe from a friend’s mom. She brought this pie to my Bridal Shower few years back, and I just about died! I saw heaven as soon as I bit into it. (I really hope that there’s frozen pies in heaven…keeping my fingers crossed.)
I hunted her down a few days after my shower and we finally got her mom to give up the recipe. I thought it was going to be this extensive recipe with some intimidating method that I was going to be afraid to try… thank goodness it was none of that. It is soooo easy! The hardest part is waiting for it to freeze.
Like 5 hours. But it’s worth it!
The first time I made it I inhaled it; no surprise there.
The next time I made it my dad and I wolfed it down in one sitting. Two forks, one pie, and a father-daughter conversation.
We plan to repeat that today. The pie is in the freezer – chillin’.
- 1 1/4 cups graham cracker crumbs or Oreo cookie crumbs
- 1/4 cup butter , melted
- 1 package (8 oz.) cream cheese, softened
- 1/3 cup sugar
- 1/3 cup smooth peanut butter
- 2 cups thawed whipped topping
- 1/2 cup chopped pecans , toasted and divided
- 1/4 cup caramel ice cream topping + more for drizzling on top
- 3 to 4 tablespoons melted chocolate for topping
- In a mixing bowl mix together the crumbs and melted butter; press onto the bottom and up the sides of a 9-inch pie plate.
- In your electric mixer’s bowl beat together the cream cheese, sugar, and peanut butter. Mix well.
- Toast the pecans over medium heat for 3 minutes on your stovetop – shake them frequently so they don’t burn.
- Add the whipped topping and half of the toasted pecans to the cream cheese mixture; blend well.
- On the bottom of the cookie crust spread 1/4 cup of caramel ice cream topping.
- Spread the cream cheese mixture on top of the caramel.
- Freeze for 3 hours.
- Take out the pie and spread the rest of the pecans over the top.
- Melt some chocolate and drizzle it with a spoon across the entire pie.
- When done with the chocolate, get the caramel topping and drizzle some more.
- Put it back in the freezer for 1 hour.
- Serve.
- Keep it frozen.
WW Freestyle SmartPoints: 13
Want To Save This Recipe?
I’m linking this up to Foodbeast. Check out their awesome site for all food-related news.
I’m linking up with TidyMom – I’m Lovin’ It Fridays
Happy Father’s Day!
SUBSCRIBE TO GET FREE UPDATES & A FREE ECOOKBOOK!
GET AN EMAIL WHEN THERE'S A NEW RECIPE
30 Min
Slow Cooker
Freezer Friendly
One Pot
Low Carb
Instant Pot
Gluten Free
Keto
Chicken
Beef
What is the whipped topping? Did I miss it?
Hi Natalie! Whipped topping is also called Cool Whip. You will need 2 cups, thawed, for this recipe. I hope that helps!
UMMMMMM, THIS LOOKS CRAZY GOOD!! LOVE THE NAME, TOO!
My fave ice cream is actually frozen yogurt with peanut butter cups in them… and so, my love of frozen versions of chocolate bars was born. I’d love to try this, but one question: what do you think would be the effect of subbing whipping cream for the whipped topping? and same about just caramel instead of caramel topping? I’d rather go all natural if I can…
I actually have the same question!!!!!
Hi!! This recipe is from 2011, and that is why I didn’t see the comment. Thank you for bringing the question to my attention!! I think those are great ideas and it would work, except for the caramel… homemade caramel won’t freeze (which makes you question why caramel topping does hehe ;-)) but if you’re okay with it not being completely solid, then it’s all good. :))
Great pie and very easy to make!!!! Next time I might try peanuts instead of pecans. Thanks for sharing the recipe!
Hi Joan! Isn’t that such a yummy pie!? I am so glad you liked it!!
I’m sooooo drooling right now, Kate 😉
Thank goodness for Spicie Foodie’s YBR so I can look at all the yumminess I missed during June! That Snickurtle pie is a delicious, decandent mess for sure 😉
Well, I guess we need a few slices of that baby to eh… taste test… yeah, taste test to make sure its our favorite new pie 😉 This looks awesome!
Okay, now this is too much! I don’t think you could have done anything to make this pie even better… It has all the things I LOVE! I would inhale it too. Yum! Thanks for sharing 🙂
OMG…that looks so totally amazing!!! Good grief…you really can’t get any better with this dessert. I think it’s got to be the ultimate sweet treat! I would so much love a slice. I’m bookmarking it…gonna have to make it one of these days! 🙂
This is one seriously awesome looking pie. Wow – would love a bite or two!
I want! This is definitely on my must make list. Sinfully delicious.
Oh my…. this looks ridiculously good Kate. It’s on the treat list for sure!!
I am totally in love with that pie!! It looks perfect – as someone has said – my name is written all over it 🙂
I’m right there with you on hoping this pie is in heaven! Delectable!
Whatever you want to call this, I can tell you right now that I will take at least 3 slices. What a gorgeous summertime dessert!
Seriously Kate! What are you trying to do to us? This belongs in the pie hall of fame!
Whoa this looks AMAZING! Love all the different layers/flavors/textures 🙂
There’s not going to be any peace in this house until one of us – guess who – is able to sit down on the couch and devour this while watching Wimbledon. Not sure there will be a second spoon allowed. Your father’s a lucky man! Happy belated Father’s day.
HOLY FATMAN. I want this.
That looks sooooo good!!! Snickurtle Pie is the perfect name for it!
Too funny. I WANT to eat that baby! You really can’t go wrong with caramel, chocolate and cream cheese. 🙂
Whoa mama, now THAT’s a pie
Seriously gorgeous. I expect we will see it on Top 9! Funny, I made an ice cream pie yesterday for my husband for father’s day. Guess it’s that time of year!
The pictures are beautiful! Love the combinations – very fun 🙂
Ohhh I love anything with caramel and nuts! And if it ice cream, even better! This pie looks so scrumptious! I wish it was summer to try it right now!!!
One of the best pies i’ve ever seen!
This looks absolutely decadent! And what a show-stopper, too! Would definitely steal the limelight at any party. 🙂
Wonderful pie! Cream cheese filling is just amazing! And decoration is lovely!
Wow. Just. Wow. I think I know just the person to make it for too. It looks like so much fun, I wish we had the oreo cookie crumbs in Australia though. One day, I’m sure we will!
I think you should just name this pie DELICIOUS!! Great job Kate! This looks so yummy. I love frozen pies!
Such a fun treat! It looks like a Jackson Pollack painting. Bet it is amazing!
That looks wonderful! I am practically drooling just looking over the ingredient list…yum!!!
The top of that pie looks like a piece of art! Gorgeous! And I can see why waiting for it to freeze would be the hard part!
Great name! I am glad that you were able to get the recipe to share with us. Snickers and Turtles sound like a match made in heaven.
I’d definitely eat the whole pie if I had it in front of me! This is the perfect combination of ingredients! And turtles? My favorite :).
LOVE the name! (I just posted a dish with a mash up name too :D)… and love the delicious mess! 😉
Your snickurtle pie looks wonderful. I was going to make a snickers no bake pie this weekend for Father’s Day, but my son was jumping up and down for me to make a Whopper pie (which I did and he loved). I am not a fan of Whoppers, but I do love snickers and turtle candies. So I I would be jumping up and own for your pie. I love that you freeze it too…. makes it more of a summer dessert. Great Job and fabulous pictures as always.
OH MY… I am a little speechless. Gorgeous! And very aptly named.
I love that you scarfed this baby down with your dad…it’s totally something my dad and I would do 🙂 It looks amazing! I love frozen pies in the summer.
Oh Kate, this does sound like heaven in a frozen pie! The chocolate, the peanut butter, the whipped cream, the caramel – oh I want to eat it now!
Wow, this looks so delicious! I don’t know if I could make this, because I might not be able to stop eating it!
it’s nice freezing stuff 🙂 cause it’s bloody hot outside…
Mouthwatering pie, it looks FANTASTIC!!!! Thank you so much for sharing Kate!
This looks beyond heavenly. Great call with the Oreo crust. Ice cream pies are my favorite even though it is really hard to convince my husband that anything besides an Apple pie is worth trying!
Snickurtle, what a cool name!
I have my fingers crossed they have pie in heaven, at least this type of pie, sounds heavenly delicious. Love that chocolate drizzle on top. Thanks for sharing Kate!
um….hhmmm….WOW! simple and so tasty I would hide behind the couch and eat it!!! love it!
oh my goodness. that chocolate drizzle….is making my mouth water. i was craving chocolate this morning…..
The name totally makes sense and it looks and sounds heavenly! I made a snickers cheesecake this weekend and I would really enjoy adapting that to a “snicktrutle” cheesecake!
Kate, this is too fabulous for words! Love the title, the “mess”, the flavours. I definitely would love this baby!
…that pie is like a dream come true. Tell your father he’s the luckiest person alive today. Wowsers. BUZZED!
Snickurtle pie! I love it! This is one I most definitely want to make. Thank you for sharing the recipe with us.
Oh yeah, I can do this! I love the idea of taking two forks and just digging in.
Happy Father’s Day to your loved ones!
WOW, Kate, yummy!! I love frozen desserts like this. Mud pie is one of my all time favorites. This looks just as tempting! Hope you’re having a great Father’s Day. 🙂
Looks sooo good! I am not a big fan of snickers, but you almost make me change my mind!
Oh, my!!! You got me with the caramel covered crust…how incredible!!!
Oh my goodness!! I don’t know if I could wait for it to freeze…I might just take a spoon to it! This looks AMAZING!
I am in love with the name, Snickurtle!! So fun:-) Seriously, Holy Cats, YUM!!!! That is all I can say, because I am drooling over the delicious pics:-)
Hugs, Terra
Yaaay… the name works!! 🙂 I had no idea what to call it… I’m so glad that it sounds good. 🙂
I am making a pudding dessert today that involves chilling and I know that waiting for it to chill will be the hardest part!