Take two slices of bread and cut out shapes using pairing knife to make jack-o-lantern faces.

Preheat skillet or frying pan over medium heat.

Generously butter all four slices of bread.

Place unshaped slice butter-side-down onto skillet and add 1 slice of cheese on top.

Take the shaped slice, butter it, and put it on top of the sandwich, butter-side-up.

Grill until lightly browned and flip over.

Continue grilling until cheese is melted.

Repeat with remaining 2 slices of bread.